Skip to main content

Table 1 Inclusion and exclusion criteria for the scoping review

From: A scoping review of equity-focused implementation theories, models and frameworks in healthcare and their application in addressing ethnicity-related health inequities

Inclusion criteria

Exclusion criteria

1. English language

1. Non-English language

2. Published between January 2011 to the present (or January 2015 to the present for articles identified by hand-searching key journals)

2. Full text unavailable

3. Published prior to 2011 (or 2015 for articles identified by hand-searching key journals)

4. Commentaries, discussion or working papers, policy documents, editorials, opinions and letters, conference proceedings, quantitative research that does not meet the inclusion criteria

3. Full text available

4. Describe an equity-focused implementation science TMF, i.e. equity (or related terms like disparity or inequality) is explicitly mentioned or equity (or parity/equality) is an explicit aim of the TMF, with or without operationalisation in intervention implementation

5. Studies describing TMFs from fields other than implementation science, e.g. health equity frameworks

6. Studies describing interventions targeting non-ethnicity-related health inequities

5. Describe the use of an established implementation science TMF to implement an intervention in an Indigenous or other minoritised ethnic/’racial’ group

7. Studies in non-healthcare settings (e.g. schools, churches) without health provider involvement

8. Interventions that do not address a particular health need

9. Study protocols that lacked sufficient detail about the TMF

6. Interventions conducted in healthcare settings; this included community-based health interventions if there was health provider involvement