Guideline-based quality indicators—a systematic comparison of German and international clinical practice guidelines

Becker, Monika; Breuing, Jessica; Nothacker, Monika; Deckert, Stefanie; Brombach, Marie; Schmitt, Jochen; Neugebauer, Edmund; Pieper, Dawid

doi:10.1186/s13012-019-0918-y

Implementation Science

Table 1 CPG pairs identified

From: Guideline-based quality indicators—a systematic comparison of German and international clinical practice guidelines

CPG pair no.	Topic	German S3-CPG (abbreviation)	CPG pair (n)	International CPG (abbreviation)
1	Breast cancer	032/045OL 2012 [61]	1	SIGN breast 2013 [42]
2	Ovarian cancer	032/035OL 2013 [16]	1	SIGN ovar 2013 [44]
3	Prostate cancer	043/022OL 2014 [51]	1	CTFPHC prostate 2014 [49]
4	Colorectal cancer	021/007OL 2013 [58]	2	CTFPHC colorectal 2016 [48]
5	Colorectal cancer	021/007OL 2013 [58]	2	SIGN colorectal 2016 [33]
6	Oesophagus cancer	021/023OL 2014 [64]	1	KCE gastrointest 2012 [28]
7	Gastric cancer	032/009OL 2012 [60]	1	KCE gastrointest 2012 [28]
8	Palliative medicine	128/001OL 2015 [65]	1	ICSI palliative 2013 [45]
9	Melanoma	032/024OL 2016 [62]	1	SIGN melanoma 2017 [43]
10	Low-back pain	nvl/007 2015 [52]	1	ICSI backpain 2012 [39]
11	Kidney disease in diabetes	nvl/001d 2015 [63]	3	NICE diabtypeI 2015 [23]
12				NICE diabtypeII 2016 [24]
13				SNS diabtypeI 2012 [35]
14	Diabetes training	nvl/001f 2012 [53]	4	NICE diabtypeI 2015 [23]
15				NICE diabtypeII 2016 [24]
16				SNS diabtypeI 2012 [35]
17				ICSI diabtypeII 2014 [36]
18	Obesity	050/001 2014*⁾ [54]	4	CTFPHC obesity 2015 [50]
19				NICE obesity 2014 [29]
20				NICE weight 2014 [30]
21				ICSI obesity 2013 [31]
22	Diabetes and pregnancy	057 – 023 2014*⁾ [56]	2	NICE diabpreg 2015 [34]
23	Diabetes and pregnancy	057 – 023 2014*⁾ [56]	2	SNS diabtypeI 2012 [35]
24	Bipolar disorder	038 – 019 2012*⁾ [55]	1	NICE bipolar 2016 [32]
25	Hysterectomy for benign diseases	015 – 070 2014*⁾ [57]	1	NICE menstrual bleeding 2016 [38]
26	Long-term opioid-use in non-cancer pain	145 – 003 2014*⁾ [59]	2	ICSI pain 2016 [40]
27	Long-term opioid-use in non-cancer pain	145 – 003 2014*⁾ [59]	2	SIGN pain 2013 [41]
28	Venous thromboembolism	003 – 001 2015*⁾ [66]	2	SIGN VTEPrev 2014 [47]
29	Venous thromboembolism	003 – 001 2015*⁾ [66]	2	CCHMC VTE 2014 [46]
30	Perioperative hypothermia	001 – 018 2013*⁾ [67]	1	ICSI hypo 2014 [37]

CCHMC Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, CTFPHC Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care, ICSI Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement, KCE Belgian Healthcare Knowledge Centre, NICE National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, SIGN Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, SNS (Spanish) National Health System, OL CPG of the German Guideline Program in Oncology, nvl CPG of the National Program for Disease Management Guidelines
*⁾CPG of the scientific medical societies

Back to article page

ISSN: 1748-5908

Contact us

Submission enquiries: Access here and click Contact Us
General enquiries: info@biomedcentral.com