Skip to main content

Table 1 Study-level descriptive statistics (n = 60)

From: Application of the Expert Recommendations for Implementing Change (ERIC) compilation of strategies to health intervention implementation in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review

 

N (%)

Year published

 2016

1 (1.8)

 2017

2 (3.5)

 2018

3 (5.3)

 2019

2 (3.5)

 2020

11 (19.3)

 2021

16 (28.1)

 2022

20 (35.1)

 2023

2 (3.5)

WHO regiona

 African

36 (60.0)

 Western Pacific

7 (11.7)

 South-East Asian

7 (11.7)

 Americas

9 (15.0)

 Eastern Mediterranean

2 (3.3)

 European

2 (3.3)

Study settinga

 Healthcare

52 (86.7)

 Community

11 (18.3)

 Policy

4 (6.7)

Target health condition

 Cancer

1 (1.7)

 Chronic non-communicable disease

7 (11.7)

 General

9 (15.0)

 Infectious disease

19 (31.7)

 Maternal and child health

10 (16.7)

 Mental health and substance use

10 (16.7)

 None

2 (3.3)

 Sexual and reproductive health

2 (3.3)

Study type

 Protocol

17 (28.3)

 Empirical

43 (71.7)

Study populationa

 Patients

31 (51.7)

 Providers

43 (71.7)

 Policymakers

14 (23.3)

 Community members

8 (13.3)

 Researchers

6 (10.0)

Process evaluation or formative study designa

 Formative implementation strategy design

17 (28.3)

 Formative strategy design and prospective process evaluation

2 (3.3)

 Prospective process evaluation

20 (33.3)

 Retrospective strategy specification

9 (15.0)

 Retrospective process evaluation

3 (5.0)

 None

9 (15.0)

Impact evaluation study design

 Cluster RCT

9 (15.0)

 Individual RCT

2 (3.3)

 QE without control

13 (21.7)

 QE with control

6 (10.0)

 Prospective cohort

5 (8.3)

 Retrospective cohort

1 (1.7)

 None

24 (40.0)

IndePENDENT VARIABLE

 No Comparison

33 (0.55)

 Intervention

13 (21.7)

 Implementation strategy

14 (23.3)

 Context

0

Implementation research theory or framework useda

 Determinants

36 (60.0)

 Process

7 (11.7)

 Evaluation

24 (40.0)

Implementation outcomes measureda

 Acceptability

27 (45.0)

 Adoption

29 (48.3)

 Appropriateness

16 (26.7)

 Cost

16 (26.7)

 Feasibility

16 (26.7)

 Fidelity

26 (43.3)

 Penetration

19 (31.7)

 Sustainability

17 (28.3)

 Health outcomes measured

25 (41.7)

  1. RCT Randomized control trial, QE Quasi-experimental
  2. a ≥ 1 response per study possible