Development | Content validity (COSMIN box 1 and 2) | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Concept elicitation (COSMIN box 1a) | Relevance | Comprehensiveness | Comprehensibility | |||||
Instrument (ref) | COSMIN Quality rating | Sample involved? | Rating of results | Quality of evidence | Rating of results | Quality of evidence | Rating of results | Quality of evidence |
Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low* | (–) | Very Low* | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
EBPAS-50 [45] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob) | (–) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (incon + rob) | |
Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
EBP Beliefs-Short [102] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
EBP Implement-Short [102] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Ethiopian EBP Implement [111] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
Al Zoubi Questionnaire [62] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
EBPP-S [63] | Inadequate | No | ( ±) | Very low * | (–) | Very low * | -- | -- |
Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
Bernhardsson [65] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
EPIC [68] | Doubtful | No | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
MPAS [71] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | (–) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
EBPPAS [73] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
SE-EBP [76] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
EBPSE [78] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
EBP Capability Beliefs [79] | Inadequate | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
HEAT [80] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
EBP-KABQ [81] | Doubtful | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Doubtful | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
HS-EBP [85] | Adequate | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Inadequate | No | ( ±) | Very low * | (-) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | |
Doubtful | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
ISP-D [93] | Adequate | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
EBNAQ [95] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
Diermayr [96] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | (-) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |
Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | |
EIDM competence measure [107] | Adequate | Yes | ( +) | Moderate (rob) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Moderate (rob) |
I-SABE [108] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
Noor EBM [109] | Doubtful | Yes | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Low (rob × 2) |
EBP-CBFRI [110] | Doubtful | No | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * | ( +) | Very low * |