From: Quantitative measures of health policy implementation determinants and outcomes: a systematic review
Tool name | Number of items | Development Author, year | Empirical use Author, year Setting/topic, country | Implementation outcomes and determinants assessed | Pragmatic PAPERS scorea | Psychometric properties assessed |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Carasso User Fee Removal Questionnaire | 18 | Carasso et al. 2012 [64] | Carasso et al. 2012 [64] Healthcare, Zambia | Organizational culture/climate, readiness to implement | 10 | Normsb |
Domain-Specific Innovativeness | 6 | Adapted from Goldsmith 1991 [65] | Webster et al. 2013 [66] Schools, physical activity, USA | Adoption | 10 | Norms, internal consistency |
Evidence-Based Practice Attitude Scale | 15 | Aarons et al. 2010 [67] | Gill et al. 2014 [68], Beidas et al. 2013 [52] Mental health, USA, Canada | Acceptability, feasibility | 12 | Norms, internal consistency, structural validityb |
Environmental Assessment Instrument | 133 | Lavinghouze et al. 2009 [69] | Lavinghouze et al. 2009 [69] Oral health, USA | Organizational culture/climate, champions, readiness to implement, structure of organization, actor relationships/networks, visibility of policy role/actors, political will for implementation | 16 | Norms |
Health Enhancing Physical Activity Policy Audit Tool | 75 | Bull et al. 2014 [70] | Bull et al. 2015 [71] Physical activity, Europe | Readiness to implement, actor relationships/networks, political will for implementation, target population characteristics affecting implementation | 12 | Norms |
Fall Prevention Coalition Survey | 203 | Schneider et al. 2016 [72] | Schneider et al. 2016 [72] Community, injury prevention, USA | Organizational culture/climate, champions, readiness to implement, actor relationships/network, visibility policy actors | 7 | Norms |
Health Disparities Collaborative Staff Survey | 21 | Helfrich et al. 2007 [73] | Helfrich et al. 2007 [73] Healthcare, chronic disease, USA | Appropriateness, feasibility, adaptability, organizational climate/culture | 8 | Not reported |
Healthy Cities Questionnaire | 125 | Donchin et al. 2006 [74] | Donchin et al. 2006 [74] Community, health promotion, Israel | Communication of policy, leadership for implementation, resources (non-training), actor relationships/networks, visibility of policy role/actors, political will for implementation | 10 | Normsb |
Konduri Disease Registry Survey | 12 | Were et al. 2010 [75] | Konduri et al. 2017 [76] Hospital/clinics, tuberculosis, Ukraine | Acceptability, feasibility, readiness to implement | 11 | Norms, internal consistency |
Local Wellness Policy Survey | 39 | McDonnell and Probart 2008 [77] | McDonnell and Probart 2008 [77] Schools—nutrition, physical activity, USA | Acceptability, readiness to implement, actor relationships/networks | 10 | Norms |
Logical Assessment Matrix | 9 | Mersini et al. 2017 [78] | Mersini et al. 2017 [78] Nutrition, Albania | Adoption, costs of implementation, penetration, target population characteristics affecting implementation | 13 | Not reported |
Maternal Child and Newborn Health Indicators | 13 | Cavagnero et al. 2008 [79] | Cavagnero et al. 2008 [79] Healthcare, global | Penetration, cost | 7 | Not reported |
Organizational Readiness for Change | 125 | Lehman et al. 2002 [80] | Lau and Brookman-Frazee 2016 [45] Gill et al. 2014 [68] Mental health, USA | Organizational culture/climate | 14 | Norms |
Perceived Attributes of Physical Activity Promotion in the Academic Classroom (PAPAC) | 18 | Adapted from Pankratz et al. 2002 [81] | Webster et al. 2018 [66] Schools, physical activity, USA | Appropriateness, feasibility, complexity, relative advantage | 10 | Normsb |
Perceived Characteristics of Intervention Scale | 20 | Cook et al. 2015 [82] | Lau and Brookman-Frazee 2016 [45] Mental health, USA | Appropriateness, feasibility, adaptability, readiness to implement, relative advantage | 13 | Norms, structural validityb |
Probart School Wellness Survey | 39 | Probart et al. 2010 [83]; Probart et al. 2008 [84]; McDonnell and Probart 2008 [77] | Probart et al. 2010 Schools, nutrition, physical activity, USA | Adoption, cost, fidelity/compliance, adaptability, organizational climate/culture | 9 | Norms, internal consistency |
Rakic Quality and Safety Survey | 50 | Rakic et al. 2018 [85] | Rakic et al. 2018 [85] Healthcare QI, Bosnia and Herzegovina | Acceptability, appropriateness, feasibility, complexity, organizational culture/climate, readiness to implement, actor relationships/networks | 10 | Norms |
Rozema Outdoor Smoking Ban Survey | 14 | Rozema et al. 2018 [86] | Rozema et al. 2018 [86] Schools, tobacco, Netherlands | Fidelity/compliance, organizational culture/climate, readiness to implement | 14 | Norms, internal consistency |
School Tobacco Policy Index | 40 | Barbero et al. 2013 [87] | Barbero et al. 2013 [87] Schools, tobacco, USA | Fidelity/compliance, communication of policy, resources (non-training), visibility of policy role/actors | 17 | Norms |
Specialty Care Transformation Survey | 26 | Williams et al. 2017 [88] | Williams et al. 2017 [88] Healthcare, access to care, USA | Appropriateness, organizational culture/climate, readiness to implement, leadership for implementation | 10 | Norms |
Spencer Quality Improvement Survey | 120 | Spencer and Walshe 2009 [89] | Spencer and Walshe 2009 [89] Healthcare, quality improvement, European Union | Readiness to implement, leadership for implementation, actor relationships/networks | 8 | Norms |
Tobacco Industry Interference Index | 20 | Assunta and Dorotheo 2016 [90] | Assunta and Dorotheo 2016 [90] Tobacco, Southeast Asia | Policy implementation climate, visibility of policy role/actors, political will for implementation | 13 | Not reported |
Tummers’ Diagnosis Related Group Policy Survey 2 | 21 | Tummers 2012 [91] | Tummers and Bekkers 2014 [92] Mental or behavioral health, Netherlands | Acceptability, adoption, appropriateness, feasibility, adaptability, champions, organizational culture/climate, relative priority, readiness to implement | 11 | Normsb |