Effectiveness of training methods for delivery of evidence-based psychotherapies: a systematic review

Valenstein-Mah, Helen; Greer, Nancy; McKenzie, Lauren; Hansen, Lucas; Strom, Thad Q.; Wiltsey Stirman, Shannon; Wilt, Timothy J.; Kehle-Forbes, Shannon M.

doi:10.1186/s13012-020-00998-w

Implementation Science

Table 3 Discrete ERIC implementation strategies (Powell et al. 2015) used in EBP training methods in included studies

From: Effectiveness of training methods for delivery of evidence-based psychotherapies: a systematic review

Study (first author and year)	EBP Mental health condition	Training methods evaluated	Implementation strategies
Study (first author and year)	EBP Mental health condition	Training methods evaluated	Distribute educational materials	Facilitate relay of clinical data to providers	Make training dynamic	Provide clinical supervision	Learning collaborative	Other
Bearman 2017 [25]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Youth depression	In-person workshop + experiential supervision			X	X		X (supervision dynamic)
Bearman 2017 [25]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Youth depression	In-person workshop + supervision as usual			X	X
Beidas 2012 [26]	Cognitive behavioral therapy, Coping Cat protocol Youth anxiety	In person didactic workshop + virtual consultation				X
		Online training + virtual consultation				X
		In-person didactic/experiential workshop + virtual consultation			X	X
Bennett-Levy 2012 [27]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Depression, panic disorder, with agoraphobia, generalized anxiety disorder	Online training			X
Bennett-Levy 2012 [27]		Online training + supportive calls			X			X (supportive calls to providers)
Chu 2017 [28]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Youth anxiety	Online training + online expert streaming consultation				X (watch streamed)
		Online training + in-person peer consultation					X
		Online training + fact sheet self-study	X
Cohen 2016 [29]	Trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy PTSD and depression	Online training + online consultation course			X	X (automated)
Cohen 2016 [29]		Online training + in person workshop + phone consultation			X	X
Cooper 2017 [30]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Eating disorders	Online training			X
Cooper 2017 [30]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Eating disorders	Online training + supportive calls			X			X (supportive calls to providers)
Dimeff 2009 [31]	Dialectical behavior therapy Borderline personality disorder	Online training			X
		In-person workshop
		Treatment manual	X
Dimeff 2011 [32]	Dialectical behavior therapy Borderline personality disorder	Online training			X
		Placebo online training
		Treatment manual	X
Dimeff 2015 [33]	Dialectical behavior therapy Borderline personality disorder	Online training			X
		In-person workshop			X
		Treatment manual	X
Fu 2015 [34]	Motivational interviewing Smoking cessation	In-person workshop			X
Fu 2015 [34]	Motivational interviewing Smoking cessation	In-person workshop + booster sessions + peer coaching			X	X	X
Gega 2007 [35]	Exposure therapy Phobias	Online training
Gega 2007 [35]	Exposure therapy Phobias	In-person workshop
Harned 2011 [36]	Exposure therapy Anxiety disorders	Online training			X
		Online training + motivational interviewing			X			X (motivational component for providers to adopt EBP)
		Placebo online training
Harned 2014 [37]	Exposure therapy Anxiety disorders	Online training			X
		Online training + motivational enhancement			X			X (motivational component for providers to adopt EBP)
		Online training + motivational enhancement + learning community					X (with expert)
Henggeler 2008 [38]	Contingency management Marijuana abuse	In-person workshop			X
Henggeler 2008 [38]	Contingency management Marijuana abuse	In-person workshop + Intensive Quality Assurance			X	X
Hubley 2015 [39]	Behavioral activation Depression	Online training
Hubley 2015 [39]	Behavioral activation Depression	Online placebo control training
Larson 2013 [40]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Substance abuse	Online training + supervision			X	X
Larson 2013 [40]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Substance abuse	Training manual + supervision	X			X
Martino 2011 [41]	Motivational interviewing Substance abuse	In person workshop by expert + consultation		X		X
		In person workshop by trainee + consultation		X		X		X (train-the-trainer)
		Treatment manual + didactic materials	X
McDonough 2002 [42]	Exposure therapy Phobias	In-person lecture + online training			X
McDonough 2002 [42]	Exposure therapy Phobias	In-person lecture + in-person group tutorial			X
Miller 2004 [43]	Motivational interviewing Substance abuse	In-person workshop			X
		In-person workshop + audio review and feedback		X	X
		In-person workshop + coaching			X	X
		In-person workshop + audio review and feedback + coaching		X	X	X
		Training manual + didactic videotapes	X		X
Monson 2018 [44]	Cognitive processing therapy Posttraumatic stress disorder	In-person workshop
		In-person workshop + consultation				X
		In-person workshop + consultation with session audio review		X		X		X (relay of clinical data in supervision)
Moyers 2008 [45]	Motivational interviewing Substance abuse	In-person workshop
		In-person workshop + feedback + consultation		X		X
		Training manual + didactic videotapes	X
Puspitasari 2017 [46]	Behavioral activation Depression	Distance workshop			X
Puspitasari 2017 [46]	Behavioral activation Depression	Online training
Rakovshik 2016 [47]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Panic disorder w/ agoraphobia, obsessive-compulsive disorder	Online training + consultation worksheet	X		X
		Online training + consultation worksheet + remote supervision			X	X
		Delayed training control
Rawson 2013 [48]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Stimulant dependence	In-person workshop + in-person coaching			X	X
		Distance workshop + telephone coaching			X	X
		Training manual + orientation	X
Ruzek 2014 [49]	Cognitive behavioral therapy skills Posttraumatic stress disorder	Online training			X
		Online training + telephone consultation			X	X
		No training control
Smith 2012 [50]	Motivational Interviewing Substance abuse	In-person workshop			X
		In-person workshop + session audio review		X	X
		In-person workshop + live teleconferencing supervision			X	X
Weingardt 2006 [51]	Cognitive behavioral therapy Cocaine addiction	In-person workshop
		Online training
		Delayed training control
Zatzick 2014 [52]	Motivational Interviewing Problem drinking	In-person workshop + feedback + coaching		X		X
Zatzick 2014 [52]	Motivational Interviewing Problem drinking	No training

Back to article page

ISSN: 1748-5908

Contact us

Submission enquiries: Access here and click Contact Us
General enquiries: info@biomedcentral.com