Skip to main content

Table 2 Toolkit element and data summary

From: Spread tools: a systematic review of components, uptake, and effectiveness of quality improvement toolkits

Study ID
Topic
Implementation toolkit element Provider toolkit element Patient toolkit element Other intervention Uptake data Feasibility data Procedure data Provider data Patient data
Ashiru-Oredope 2016
Antimicrobial stewardship (AMS)
x x    x   x   
Jones 2017
Antimicrobial stewardship (AMS)
NA NA NA x x x x x  
Bender 2011
Asthma management
x x x x x   x   
Taylor 2017
Asthma management
x x x x      x
Nicolaidis 2016
Autism communication
x x x x   x    x
Chrisman 2011
Brain injury symptom management
x x x      x  
Latsko 2015
Cancer care
x x x   x    x  
Gulati 2015
Cancer screening
  x   x x x x x  
Spruce 2012
Cancer screening
x x x    x   x  
Adsett 2014
Cardiac care
x x x    x    
Callard 2012
Care quality
x   x   x     
Kemertzis 2018
Clinical decision making
x x x x x x x x  
Pierce 2016
Critical care
x     x x x   
Han 2013
Depression care
x x x   x x   x  
Fowles 2014
Diabetes care
x x x x     x x
Gray 2017
Diabetes care
NA NA NA x   x x x  
Alidina 2015
Elective delivery
x x x   x   x   x
Chesis 2015
Elective delivery
NA NA NA x    x   
Clancy 2012
Emergency preparedness
x x x   x x x   
Wyte-Lake 2016
Emergency preparedness
x x   x   x    
Henry 2012
Emergency/surgery capacity
x x   x x   x   
Cox 2017
End-of-life care
x x   x     x x
Carroll 2012
Fall prevention
  x x     x   
Coe 2017
Fall prevention
x x x x x x x   
Dykes 2017
Fall prevention
NA NA NA   x x x   x
Fisher 2013
Fall prevention
x x    x     x
Stalhandske 2008
Fall prevention
x x x x    x   x
Ryan 2013
Geriatric care
x x x x x    x  
Dore 2013
Health literacy
x x x x x x x x  
Mabachi 2016
Health literacy
    x x x   x  
Koelling 2006
Heart failure
x x x x      x
Perumalswami 2016
Hepatitis C care
  x x   x     
Adams 2014
Hospital readmission
x x x x    x   x
Mitchell 20015
Hospital readmission
x x x x x x x x x
Enfield 2014
Hospital-acquired infections
x x   x x   x   x
Randle 2006
Hospital-acquired infections
x x x x   x x x x
Septimus 2016
Hospital-acquired infections
x x   x   x    x
Haley 2015
Kidney disease care
x x x x x x x x  
Fernald 2015
Medical errors
x    x x x   x  
Leape 2006
Medical errors
x x   x x x    
Mueller 2013
Medication management
x x   x   x   x  
McHugo 2007
Mental health
x x   x x   x   
MacDonald-Wilson 2017
Mental health decision support
x x x x x x   x  
Miller 2014
Multiple sclerosis symptom management
x x   x   x x x  
Guillory 2017
Newborn screening
x x x x    x x x
Dobbins 2005
Nursing best practices
x    x x x    
Main 2017
Obstetric care
x x x x x     x
Fine 2014
Pain management
x x   x    x   
Pulver 2012
Pain management
x x x     x   
Kuhlman 2014
Parental education
  x x     x   
Parkman 2013
Patient safety
x x     x   x  
Schauberger 2006
Patient safety
x    x x x x   
Thomason 2016
Patient Safety
x x   x x x   x  
Lannon 2008
Pediatric preventive care
x x x x x x x   
Byrne 2011
Perinatal care
x    x    x   
Kohler 2015
Perinatal care
x x x x    x   
Lyndon 2016
Perinatal care
x x x x   x x   
Ezzat 2017
Physical therapy
x x   x x x x x  
Brown 2015
Psychotherapy decision support
  x        x
Sopcak 2016
Screening
x x x x   x   x x
Shellhaas,2016
Screening, quality improvement
  x x x x x x x x
Sarna 2017
Smoking cessation
x x    x   x   
Shershneva 2010
Smoking cessation
x x x    x   x  
Pratt 2012
Staff trauma support
x     x x   x  
Brooks 2013
Substance abuse
  x x x x    x  
Levy 2017
Substance use screening
x x   x   x   x  
Nace 2011
Vaccination
x    x    x   
Nowalk 2014
Vaccination
x x x x x x x   
Zimmerman 2014
Vaccination
NA NA NA x x   x   
Abraham 2007
Weight management
x x x    x x   
Gibson 2016
Weight management
x x x x x x x   x
Kinsinger 2009
Weight management
x x x x x   x   
Rueda-Clausen 2014
Weight management
x x x x    x   
Sample 2013
Weight management
x x x x x x x   
Smith 2011
Weight management
x x x   x x x x  
Stiff 2014
Weight management
x x x x   x   x x
Mulloy 2008
Wrong site surgery
x x x    x    x
Frequences 89%a 88%a 63%a 69%b 55%b 56%b 57%b 40%b 29%b
  1. Note: NA not applicable (to not count the toolkit twice), MS multiple sclerosis, NICU neonatal intensive care unit
  2. aOut of 72 toolkits
  3. bOut of 77 publications