Skip to main content

Table 2 Levels of preventive care at baseline and follow-up, and estimates of the intervention effect, for both groups combined

From: Effectiveness of an intervention in increasing the provision of preventive care by community mental health services: a non-randomized, multiple baseline implementation trial

Outcome

Baseline (n = 805)

Follow-up (n = 982)

Intervention effect

p value

Odds ratio (95 % CI)

Risk assessment

    

 Smoking

610 (76 %)

805 (82 %)

0.87 (0.41–1.83)

0.712

 Nutrition

191 (24 %)

357 (36 %)

2.62 (1.25–5.52)

0.011

 Alcohol

632 (79 %)

820 (84 %)

1.83 (0.85–3.96)

0.123

 Physical activity

467 (58 %)

575 (59 %)

1.03 (0.54–1.95)

0.934

 All risks combined

146 (18 %)

297 (30 %)

3.55 (1.56–8.08)

0.002

Brief advicea

    

 Smoking

275 (67 %)

298 (65 %)

1.89 (0.73–4.92)

0.190

 Nutrition

186 (26 %)

267 (33 %)

2.43 (1.11–5.33)

0.026

 Alcohol

222 (62 %)

238 (57 %)

1.44 (0.54–3.81)

0.468

 Physical activity

234 (61 %)

191 (52 %)

0.38 (0.14–0.99)

0.048

 All applicable risks combined

185 (24 %)

250 (27 %)

1.33 (0.62–2.87)

0.468

Referrala

    

 Smoking referral (any)b

173 (42 %)

224 (48 %)

2.16 (0.86–5.4)

0.101

 Nutrition referral (any)c

128 (18 %)

174 (22 %)

1.36 (0.56–3.29)

0.493

 Alcohol referral (any)d

127 (35 %)

153 (36 %)

1.01 (0.37–2.75)

0.981

 Physical activity referral (any)c

123 (32 %)

113 (31 %)

1.04 (0.38–2.84)

0.947

 Referral—all applicable risks (any)b,c,d

0 (0 %)

12 (1.3 %)

0.93 (0.19–4.5)

0.925

 Letter to primary care provider

206 (26 %)

227 (23 %)

0.66 (0.32–1.34)

0.249

Additional referral outcomesa,e

    

 Smoking arrangef

11 (2.7 %)

11 (2.4 %)

  

 Nutrition arrangef

5 (0.7 %)

40 (5.0 %)

  

 Physical activity arrangef

7 (1.8 %)

11 (3.0 %)

  

 Smoking—primary care provider

52 (13 %)

79 (17 %)

  

 Nutrition—primary care provider

6 (0.8 %)

25 (3.1 %)

  

 Alcohol—primary care provider

38 (11 %)

41 (9.8 %)

  

 Physical activity—primary care provider

5 (1.3 %)

6 (1.6 %)

  
  1. aOf participants who reported being at-risk for each relevant behaviour
  2. bIncludes the following: clinician spoke about NSW Quitline, offered to arrange for NSW Quitline to call them, recommended they speak to their primary care provider or advised them to use any other support
  3. cIncludes the following: clinician spoke about NSW Get Healthy Service, offered to arrange for NSW Get Healthy Service to call them, recommended they speak to their primary care provider or advised them to use any other support
  4. dIncludes the following: recommended they speak to their primary care provider or advised them to use any other support
  5. eIntervention effect could not be modelled meaningfully due to small sample size
  6. fIncludes the following: clinician offered to arrange for NSW Quitline to call them (smoking) or for NSW Get Healthy Service to call them (nutrition and/or physical activity)