Skip to main content

Advertisement

Springer Nature is making SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19 research free. View research | View latest news | Sign up for updates

Table 1 Scoring rubric for documentation and recording of fidelity to the implementation strategy

From: What is the extent and quality of documentation and reporting of fidelity to implementation strategies: a scoping review

Domain Dusenburya,b definition Adapted operational definition Checklist questions
Adherence The extent to which implementation of particular activities and methods is consistent with the way the program is written Specifying the implementation strategy(s) and evidence of the extent to which this/these implementation strategy(s) took place To score 2, both conditions must be present/yes
 Condition 1: Does the study describe all implementation strategies used? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide detail on how all implementation strategies were carried out?
To score 1, both conditions must be present/yes
 Condition 1: Does the study describe some but not all implementation strategies used? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide detail on how some but not all implementation strategies were carried out?
To score 0, one condition may be present, OR no conditions may be present/yes:
 Condition 1: Does the study describe all or some implementation strategies used? OR
 Condition 2: Does the study provide detail on how all or some of the implementation strategies were carried out?
Dose The amount of the program content received by participants Proportion of intervention providers who received the implementation strategy(s) (i.e., number of people and specific strategy received) To score 2, both conditions must be present/yes:
 Condition 1: Does the study provide a description of the number of people receiving all of the implementation strategies? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the strategy or strategies all of the groups received?
To score 1, both conditions must be present/yes
 Condition 1: Does the study provide a description of the number of people receiving some but not all of the implementation strategies? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the strategy or strategies for some but not all of the groups?
To score 0, one condition may be present, OR no conditions may be present/yes:
 Condition 1: Does the study provide a description of the number of people receiving some or all of the implementation strategies? OR
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the strategy or strategies for some or all of the groups?
Participant Responsiveness The extent to which participants are engaged by and involved in the activities and content of the program Extent to which intervention providers are involved in the development of the implementation strategy, evaluation of the implementation strategy or their receptivity to the implementation strategy and extent of involvement To score 2, both conditions must be present/yes:
 Condition 1: Does the study state participants involvement in the development, evaluation, or receptivity to the implementation strategy? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the extent of participant involvement in the development, evaluation, or receptivity to the implementation strategy?
To score 1, one condition must be present/yes
 Condition 1: Does the study provide a description of the number of people receiving some but not all of the implementation strategies? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the strategy or strategies for some but not all of the groups?
To score 0, no conditions are present/yes
 Condition 1: Does the study provide a description of the number of people receiving some or all of the implementation strategies? AND
 Condition 2: Does the study provide a description of the strategy or strategies for some or all of the groups?
  1. aDusenbury [2]
  2. bWe chose not to include the Quality of Program Delivery and Program Differentiation components as part of our scoring since they relate to the fidelity to the evidence-informed intervention