Tactic | Domain | Subdomain | Attribute/subattribute/elementa |
---|---|---|---|
Developers of content | Comprehensive | Clinical experts | Multidisciplinary and multijurisdictional |
Researchers and users | |||
Target population | Individual patients | ||
Family members | |||
Groups representing patients | |||
Decision makers | Multidisciplinary and multijurisdictional | ||
Researchers and users | |||
Methodologists | Practice guideline experts | ||
Knowledge synthesis experts | |||
Health economics experts | |||
Ethicists | |||
Implementation experts | |||
Knowledgeable and credible | - | - | |
Competing interests | Financial | - | |
Professional and/or academic | |||
Advocacy | |||
Creating content | Evidence synthesis | How: execution of methods to develop evidence base | Systematic and reproducible |
Valid and reliable | |||
What: completeness of reporting evidence base | Question | ||
Eligibility criteria | |||
Literature search strategy | |||
Critical appraisal | |||
Data extraction | |||
Data synthesis | |||
Reporting | |||
When: currency of evidence base | - | ||
Deliberations and contextualization | Clinical applicability | Clinical relevance | |
Patient relevance | |||
Implementation relevance | |||
Values | Patient/client | ||
• Acceptability | |||
• Preferences | |||
Provider | |||
• Acceptability | |||
• Preferences | |||
• Clinical flexibility | |||
• Clinical judgment | |||
Guideline developer | |||
• Acceptability | |||
• Preferences | |||
Population/societal | |||
• Acceptability | |||
• Preferences | |||
• Diversity | |||
• Equity | |||
Policy | |||
• Acceptability | |||
• Preferences | |||
Feasibility | Local applicability | ||
• Local adaption | |||
• Application tools and strategies | |||
Resources | |||
• Availability of resources | |||
• Economic evaluation | |||
Novelty | |||
• Compatibility | |||
• Knowledge and skills | |||
Communicating content | Language | Simple | Succinct |
Uncomplicated | |||
Clear | Actionable | ||
• Specific | |||
• Unambiguous | |||
Effective writing | |||
Persuasive | Framing | ||
Relative advantage | |||
Format | Version | Tailored | |
Modalities | |||
• Electronic (dynamic, static) | |||
• Non-electronic | |||
Document types | |||
Components | - | ||
Presentation | Document layout | ||
• Visual elements | |||
• Length | |||
Structure | |||
• Match system to the real world | |||
• Grouping/ordering | |||
Information visualization | |||
• Display (tables, algorithms, pictures, graphical display) | |||
• Context (framing, vividness, depth of field, evaluability) |