Skip to main content

Table 1 Listing of included and excluded constructs from the organizing frameworks

From: The Society for Implementation Research Collaboration Instrument Review Project: A methodology to promote rigorous evaluation

 

Construct

Included

Excluded

CFIR domains

   

  Characteristics of individuals

Knowledge and beliefs about the intervention

X

 
 

Individual stage of change

X

 
 

Individual identification with organization

X

 
 

Other personal attributes

X

 
 

Self-efficacy

X

 

  Inner setting

Culture

X

 
 

Implementation climate (IC)

X

 

  IC: tension for changea

X

 

  IC: compatibilitya

X

 

  IC: relative prioritya

X

 

  IC: organizational incentives and rewardsa

X

 

  IC: goals and feedbacka

X

 

  IC: learning climatea

X

 
 

Networks and communications

X

 
 

Readiness for implementation (RI)

X

 

  RI: leadership engagementa

X

 

  RI: available resourcesa

X

 

  RI: access to knowledge and informationa

X

 
 

Structural characteristics

X

 

  Intervention characteristics

Adaptability

X

 
 

Complexity

X

 
 

Cost

X

 
 

Design quality and packaging

X

 
 

Evidence strength and quality

X

 
 

Intervention source

X

 
 

Relative advantage

X

 
 

Trialability

X

 

  Outer setting

Cosmopolitanism

X

 
 

External policy and incentives

X

 
 

Patient needs and resources

X

 
 

Peer pressure

X

 

  Process

Engaging

X

 

  Engaging: opinion leadersa

X

 

  Engaging: formally appointed internala

X

 

Implementation leadersa

  

  Engaging: championsa

X

 

  Engaging: external change agentsa

X

 
 

Executing

X

 
 

Planning

X

 
 

Reflecting and evaluating

X

 

  Implementation outcomes framework

   

  Service outcomes

Effectiveness

 

X

 

Efficiency

 

X

 

Equity

 

X

 

Patient-centeredness

 

X

 

Safety

 

X

 

Timeliness

 

X

  Client outcomes

Function

 

X

 

Satisfaction

X

 
 

Symptomology

 

X

  Implementation outcomes

Acceptability

X

 
 

Adoption

X

 
 

Appropriateness

X

 
 

Cost

X

 
 

Feasibility

X

 
 

Fidelity

X

 
 

Penetration

X

 
 

Sustainability

X

 

Total

 

48

8

  1. There are 34 main constructs with a total of 48 including subconstructs. Adapted from Damschroder et al. [7] (http://www.implementationscience.com/content/4/1/50/additional/) and Proctor et al. [8].
  2. CFIR Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research.
  3. aSubconstructs.