Table 3 Mapping of themes and sub-themes across surgeons
Characteristics | Typology | Conceptual | Methodological | Practical | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Surgeon 4 | Baseline performance | Advocate | PROMs V Satisfaction | Interpretation | Support/infrastructure |
(OHS): Above average | (value and impact) | Timing | |||
Setting: Mixed | Validity | ||||
Experience: Moderate | |||||
Surgeon 7 | Baseline performance | Advocate | PROMs V Clinical | Interpretation | Support/infrastructure |
(OHS): Below average | (value and impact) | Focus/variability | |||
Setting: Public | Validity | ||||
Experience: Minimal | |||||
Surgeon 2 | Baseline performance | Convert | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Below average | (undecided and no impact) | PROMs V Satisfaction | Validity | Support/infrastructure | |
Setting: Public | |||||
Experience: Moderate | |||||
Surgeon 3 | Baseline performance | Convert | PROMs V Satisfaction | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Above average | (undecided and no impact) | PROMs V Clinical | Focus/variability | Support/infrastructure | |
Setting: Private | Validity | ||||
Experience: Minimal | |||||
Surgeon 5 | Baseline performance | Convert | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Above average | (undecided and no impact) | PROMs V Satisfaction | Focus/variability | Support/infrastructure | |
Setting: Public | Timing | ||||
Experience: None | Validity | ||||
Surgeon 6 | Baseline performance | Convert | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Support/infrastructure |
(OHS): Below average | (undecided and no impact) | Validity | |||
Setting: Public | |||||
Experience: Minimal | |||||
Surgeon 1 | Baseline performance | Sceptic | n/a | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Above average | (no value and no impact) | Measurement | Support/infrastructure | ||
Setting: Public | Timing | ||||
Experience: Minimal | Validity | ||||
Surgeon 8 | Baseline performance | Sceptic | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Below average | (no value and no impact) | PROMs V Satisfaction | Focus/variability | ||
Setting: Mixed | Validity | ||||
Experience: None | |||||
Surgeon 9 | Baseline performance | Sceptic | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | n/a |
(OHS): Above average | (no value and no impact) | Focus/variability | |||
Setting: Mixed | Timing | ||||
Experience: None | Validity | ||||
Surgeon 10 | Baseline performance | Sceptic | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Support/infrastructure |
(OHS): Below average | (no value and no impact) | PROMs V Satisfaction | Focus/variability | ||
Setting: Mixed | PROMs V Clinical | Timing | |||
Experience: Minimal | Validity | ||||
Surgeon 11 | Baseline performance | Sceptic | Subjective measurement | Interpretation | Time/workload |
(OHS): Above average | (no value and no impact) | PROMs V Satisfaction | Focus/variability | ||
Setting: Mixed | PROMs V Clinical | Timing | |||
Experience: Minimal | Validity |