Skip to main content

Table 4 Independent assessment of postnatal depression innovations (allocation of criteria)

From: Exploring the feasibility of Conjoint Analysis as a tool for prioritizing innovations for implementation

Innovation

Impact on care

Strength of evidence

Local health needs

Costs

Local expertise

Min. standards

Priority

NICE diagnostic questions

Limited

No evidence

High

Low

Yes

No

Local

Guided self help

Moderate

Moderate

High

Low

Yes

No

National and local

Computerised CBT

Limited

Moderate

High

Low

Yes

No

National and local

Exercise

Limited

Limited

High

Moderate

Yes

No

Local

Health visitor listening visits

Moderate

Moderate

High

Moderate

Yes

No

National and local

Practice counsellor referral

Moderate

Moderate

High

High

Yes

No

National and local

Brief CBT

Limited

Limited

High

Moderate

Yes

No

National and local

Full CBT

Moderate

Limited

High

High

Yes

No

National and local

Anti- depressants

Limited

Limited

High

Low

Yes

No

Local

Anti-depressants and psychological therapies together

Limited

Moderate

High

Low

Yes

No

Local

EPDS diagnostic tool

Moderate

Limited

High

Low

Yes

No

Local