Table 5 Comparison of CPG quality according to independent variables
Median [Interquartile range] of standardized domain scores | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scope | Participation | Rigour | Clarity | Applicability | Independence | |
Diffusion year | ||||||
Period 1994–2000 (n = 22) | 39% [40%] | 15% [22%] | 6% [10%] | 42% [46%] | 6% [17%] | 0% [0%] |
Year 2001 (n = 13) | 33% [47%] | 12% [29%] | 10% [15%] | 42% [46%] | 0% [19%] | 0% [0%] |
Year 2002 (n = 19) | 33% [28%] | 8% [17%] | 10% [15%] | 50% [67%] | 6% [6%] | 0% [8%] |
Year 2003 (n = 28) | 39% [29%] | 13% [13%] | 12% [11%] | 43% [40%] | 11% [19%] | 0% [0%] |
Year 2004 (n = 19) | 28% [39%] | 13% [17%] | 8% [14%] | 33% [25%] | 6% [11%] | 0% [8%] |
P value | 0,66 | 0,89 | 0,28 | 0,68 | 0,52 | 0,72 |
Publication | ||||||
Published (n = 39) | 39% [33%] | 13% [46%] | 10% [14%] | 42% [29%] | 6% [17%] | 0% [0%] |
Not Published (n = 62) | 39% [33%] | 10% [13%] | 12% [14%] | 44% [38%] | 11% [17%] | 0% [0%] |
P value | 0,93 | 0.76 | 0,23 | 0,40 | 0,24 | 0,43 |
Level of the Health System | ||||||
Macro (n = 12) | 42% [44%] | 13% [15%] | 11% [13%] | 61% [42%] | 11% [18%] | 0% [0%] |
Meso (n = 25) | 28% [31%] | 8% [13%] | 12% [12%] | 37% [37%] | 6% [11%] | 0% [0%] |
Micro (n = 49) | 39% [32%] | 13% [17%] | 7% [14%] | 41% [28%] | 6% [11%] | 0% [0%] |
More than one level (n = 15) | 39% [50%] | 21% [13%] | 12% [17%] | 41% [37%] | 6% [22%] | 0% [0%] |
P value | 0,12 | 0,01 | 0,24 | 0,11 | 0,21 | 0,94 |
Guideline Scope | ||||||
National CPG (n = 74) | 39% [33%] | 13% [13%] | 10% [15%] | 42% [34%] | 6% [18%] | 0% [0%] |
Regional/Local CPG (n = 27) | 28% [25%] | 8 % [13%] | 12% [14%] | 38% [38%] | 6% [11% ] | 0% [0%] |
P value | 0.11 | 0.12 | 0.24 | 0.52 | 0.35 | 0.4 |
CPG category | ||||||
Dx/treatment management (n = 71) | 39% [28%] | 13% [13%] | 9% [14%] | 42% [33%] | 6% [17%] | 0% [0%] |
Prevention (n = 25) | 39% [50%] | 13% [19%] | 9% [12%] | 54% [35%] | 6% [17%] | 0% [0%] |
P value | 0,19 | 0,33 | 0,53 | 0,02 | 0,85 | 0,77 |