Trial comparison | Design | Hypothesis | Hawthorne |
---|---|---|---|
Arm I vs. II Complete intervention on lot A. Using lot B as control. | Block | If the test scores related to lot A vignettes increase in accordance with Clinical Evidence chapters A and there is no change in test scores of B chapters, the intervention has a genuine effect. | No |
Arm II vs. I Complete intervention on lot B. Using lot A as control. | Block | If the test scores related to lot B vignettes increase in accordance with Clinical Evidence chapters B and there is no change in test scores of A chapters, the intervention has a genuine effect. | No |
Arm I vs. III Complete intervention for lot A (ECCE). Minimal intervention on A-B chapters (Clinical Evidence) (control). | Classical | If the test scores related to A vignettes in the intervention arm increase in accordance with the Clinical Evidence chapters A and there is no change in the control arm the intervention (ECCE) has a favourable effect, but without controlling for the Hawthorne effect. | Yes |
Arm II vs. III Complete intervention for lot B (ECCE). Minimal intervention on A-B chapters (Clinical Evidence) (control). | Classical | If the test scores related to lot B vignettes in the intervention arm increase in accordance with the Clinical Evidence chapters B and there is no change in the control arm the intervention (ECCE) has a favourable effect, but without controlling for the Hawthorne effect. | Yes |